Cross-purchase or entity redemption?
| Cross-purchase | Entity redemption | |
|---|---|---|
| Who buys | Surviving owners | The company |
| Who owns the insurance | Each owner, on the others | The company |
| Buyer's cost basis | Survivors get a higher basis in the new shares | Survivors' basis generally doesn't step up |
| Complexity | Grows with the number of owners | Simpler with many owners |
| Estate tax note | — | Under the Supreme Court's 2024 Connelly decision, company-owned insurance proceeds can raise the company's value for estate tax |
The Connelly v. United States decision (2024) made many owners revisit company-owned policies used to fund redemptions. Agreements written before 2024 deserve a fresh look with an attorney.
What should a good agreement cover?
- All the triggers, not just death.
- A clear, current way to set the price, updated regularly. A price set years ago and never updated is a common failure.
- Funding that matches the price, with insurance amounts reviewed as the business grows.
- Payment terms if insurance doesn't cover everything.
- Disability definitions and waiting periods that match the disability buyout policy.
- Coordination with each owner's estate plan.
What goes wrong most often?
Prices set at founding and never updated. Insurance that lapsed or was never bought. Policies owned by the wrong party. Disability ignored. Heirs and survivors arguing over the value in court. And an agreement nobody has read in a decade.
Your one move
Pull your buy-sell agreement and answer four questions: When was it last updated? How is the price set, and what would it say today? Is the funding in place, for death and disability? Is it company-owned or cross-owned insurance, and has anyone reviewed it since Connelly ? Bring the answers to your attorney and adviser.