Debt

Good Debt vs. Bad Debt: When Borrowing Helps and When It Hurts

The short answer

Debt helps when the thing you borrowed for earns more than the loan costs, and you could still make the payments in a bad year. It hurts when it pays for things that lose value, carries a high interest rate, or has payments that only work if everything goes right. Start by paying off high-interest debt like credit cards. Then judge every other loan by its cost, its payments and who is on the hook if it fails.

The same tool that buys a home, starts a business or grows a rental portfolio can also turn one bad year into a crisis. The interest rate alone doesn't decide which.

Words to know

Interest rate
the yearly cost of borrowing, as a percentage of what you owe.
Amortizing loan
a loan you pay down a little with every payment until it reaches zero, like most mortgages and car loans.
Interest-only or revolving debt
you pay interest but the balance doesn't have to shrink. Credit cards and credit lines work this way.
Debt-to-income ratio
your monthly debt payments divided by your monthly gross income. Lenders often want it at or below about 36%.
Personal guarantee
your promise to repay someone else's loan, often your business's, if they can't.

What makes debt "good"?

Ask three questions about each loan:

  1. Does it earn more than it costs? A loan for a rental property whose rent covers its costs, or for a business purchase that earns well above the interest rate, can build wealth. A loan for a vacation or a car that loses value can't.
  2. Could you make the payments in a bad year? Picture your income 30–40% lower for a year. If the payments still work, the debt is probably sized right.
  3. Does it have an end date? Loans that shrink on a schedule build in discipline. Balances you only pay interest on can quietly last for years.

Why does debt make bad years worse?

Because payments don't shrink when your income does. Research by Federal Reserve economist Karen Dynan, published by the Brookings Institution in 2012, found that heavily indebted households cut their spending more sharply when times got tough. Their debt payments left them less room to adjust.

That risk applies to everyone, but it's sharper if your income is uneven, as it is for business owners, commission earners, freelancers and anyone whose bonus is a large part of their pay.

What about credit cards?

Credit card interest rates are often above 20%. Paying off a card charging 22% is like earning a guaranteed 22% on that money, and no investment reliably does that. A 2012 study in the Journal of Economic Psychology found that people who carry expensive card balances usually aren't making a calculated choice. Habits, impulse and optimism about future income keep the balances around.

Income doesn't protect you here. Someone earning $500,000 who carries a $40,000 balance at 22% is handing the bank about $8,800 a year.

Should I pay off debt or invest?

A simple order works for most people:

  1. Pay off high-interest debt first: credit cards and anything above roughly 8–10%.
  2. Get every tax break and free match available: for example, contribute enough to your 401(k) to get the full employer match.
  3. Then compare. For low-rate debt like many mortgages, investing extra money may come out ahead over long periods, but investment returns aren't guaranteed. Paying down debt is a sure return. People who sleep better debt-free can reasonably choose that.
  4. Shrink personal guarantees. If you've guaranteed business or property loans worth a large share of your net worth, paying those down can be worth more than chasing a higher return.

Your one move

Make a "debt list" on one page: every loan and card, with the balance, interest rate, monthly payment, payoff date, and whether you've personally guaranteed it. Add up your monthly payments and divide by your monthly gross income. Then put any extra money toward the highest-rate item on the list.

Next steps

In the Guide

Chapter 3: Debt: the order of operations

Get the free Guide

Then

Find your blind spots

Take the Wealth Builder Score

Sources

  1. Dynan, K. (2012). Is a household debt overhang holding back consumption? Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Spring 2012.
  2. Gathergood, J. (2012). Self-control, financial literacy and consumer over-indebtedness. Journal of Economic Psychology, 33(3).
  3. Dollar examples are hypothetical illustrations.