Why does it matter how an adviser is paid?
Whoever pays someone shapes what they do. You already know this from hiring contractors, salespeople or employees. Financial advice works the same way.
The research backs this up. A 2013 study in the Journal of Finance found that brokers steered clients' money toward funds that paid the brokers more, not toward funds with better track records. A 2012 study of a large German brokerage found that clients who leaned on advisers paid more in costs and earned lower returns than people who managed their own accounts.
None of that means commission-paid people are bad people. Most believe in what they sell. The point is that the pay structure tilts the playing field, even for honest professionals.
What's the difference between the three models?
Fee-only. You pay the adviser directly, and that's their only income from you. Whether they recommend a fund, an insurance policy or doing nothing at all, their pay doesn't change. That doesn't make them perfect, but the biggest conflict is gone.
Fee-based. You pay a fee for some services, and the adviser can also earn commissions on others. They may be required to act in your best interest, and they must disclose the conflict. But disclosure doesn't remove the conflict. It just makes it visible, as long as you read the paperwork.
Commission. The adviser is paid only when you buy something. That's a sales job. The person may be knowledgeable and well-meaning, but nobody is paying them to tell you that you don't need what they sell.
Where do commissions usually show up?
Mostly in the products that make people's eyes glaze over:
- Permanent life insurance. First-year commissions often equal a large share of the first year's premium.
- Annuities. Commissions are commonly several percent of the amount invested, and surrender charges can lock your money up for years.
- Mutual funds with sales loads and ongoing 12b-1 fees.
- Long-term care insurance.
These products aren't bad in themselves. Many have a real place in a plan. The question is whether the recommendation came from your needs or from the commission.
Isn't this only a concern for people with a lot of money?
No. A worker rolling over a $90,000 401(k) and a family investing $9 million from a business sale face the same question. Bigger, more complicated finances just mean more recommendations, and more chances for a conflict to shape one of them.
Being wealthy doesn't come with a briefing on how advisers get paid. Most successful people have never been told.
Your one move
Ask anyone advising you:
"Will you list, in writing, every way you or your firm get paid if I follow your recommendations, including commissions, fund fees and payments from other companies?"
A fee-only adviser can answer in one sentence. For anyone else, read their Form ADV Part 2A, a plain-language brochure every registered adviser must give you. It explains how they are paid. You can also look it up free at adviserinfo.sec.gov.