Getting Good Advice

What Should Happen in a Financial Planning Meeting? The 7 Steps

The short answer

Real financial planning follows seven steps, in order. The planner understands your situation, sets clear goals with you, measures the gap, builds recommendations, explains them, helps put them in place, and keeps checking. CFP® professionals must follow this process when they do financial planning. If your adviser's first meeting ends with a product to buy, they skipped most of it.

The early steps are where the value is. That's where someone learns enough about you to give advice that fits you instead of a generic client.

Words to know

Financial planning
working out where you are, where you want to go and how to get there, across your whole financial life, not just investments.
Scope of engagement
the written agreement on which parts of your finances the planner will cover.
Gap analysis
comparing where you're headed if nothing changes with where you want to be.

Does planning actually make a difference?

Research suggests yes. A 2003 study in the Quarterly Journal of Economics found that households with a stronger habit of planning built more wealth than similar households without it. Income and education didn't explain the difference.

Goal-setting research points the same way. In a 2002 review of 35 years of studies in American Psychologist, Edwin Locke and Gary Latham found that specific, challenging goals lead to better results than vague "do your best" goals.

The seven steps, and what skipping each looks like

  1. Understand your situation. That means income, savings, debts, insurance, taxes, estate documents, family and any business you own, plus what matters to you. Skipped looks like: questions about your "risk tolerance," then a proposal to move your accounts.
  2. Set goals together. Not "retire comfortably," but "$9,000 a month starting at 63, adjusted for inflation" or "pay for two kids' college without touching retirement." Skipped looks like: "moderate risk, retire early 60s, maybe."
  3. Measure the gap. Where will you end up if nothing changes, and what are the options for closing the gap? Skipped looks like: a recommended portfolio with no projection of whether it gets you there.
  4. Build recommendations that fit together. Investments, taxes, insurance and estate plans affect each other. A good plan coordinates them. Skipped looks like: separate advice in each area that nobody checked against the others.
  5. Explain the recommendations. You should hear the why, the alternatives that were rejected, the assumptions and the risks. You should be able to push back. Skipped looks like: "Sign here."
  6. Put the plan in place. That includes working with your accountant and attorney so the non-investment pieces actually happen. Skipped looks like: the accounts get moved, but the will, beneficiaries and insurance never get updated.
  7. Keep checking. Life changes, laws change and markets move. The plan should be reviewed regularly, and the planner should reach out when something big shifts. Skipped looks like: a once-a-year performance review, and nothing else unless you call.

Is this only for wealthy families?

No. A young family with a mortgage and a 401(k) needs the same seven steps, just with fewer moving parts. A family with a business, real estate and trusts has more pieces to coordinate, so skipping steps costs more. Either way, the process is what turns advice into a plan.

Your one move

Bring these seven questions to your next meeting, one per step:

  1. "How did you learn about my whole situation before making recommendations?"
  2. "What exactly are my goals, in dollars and dates?"
  3. "Where am I headed if I change nothing?"
  4. "How do these recommendations work together?"
  5. "What alternatives did you consider, and what are you assuming?"
  6. "Who makes sure my accountant and attorney get their parts done?"
  7. "How often will we review this, and when will you call me without my asking?"

Next steps

Sources

  1. CFP Board (2019). Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct, Practice Standards for the Financial Planning Process.
  2. Ameriks, J., Caplin, A., & Leahy, J. (2003). Wealth accumulation and the propensity to plan. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(3).
  3. Locke, E., & Latham, G. (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation. American Psychologist, 57(9).