Protection

How to Think About Risk: Avoid It, Shrink It, Keep It or Insure It

The short answer

Every financial risk can be handled four ways. Avoid it (don't do the risky thing). Reduce it (make it less likely or less costly). Retain it (pay for it yourself if it happens). Or transfer it (insure it). The rule of thumb: insure the rare events that would be catastrophic, keep the small, frequent ones, and reduce everything you reasonably can. Most people do the opposite. They insure small things and leave the catastrophic ones exposed.

Insurance is the last line of defense, not the whole plan.

Words to know

Risk management
a method for deciding how to handle what could go wrong.
Frequency vs. severity
how often something happens, and how bad it is when it does.
Deductible / elimination period
the part you pay, or the time you wait, before insurance kicks in.
Self-insure
choosing to cover a risk from your own savings.
Premium
what you pay for insurance.

How do the four choices work?

RareFrequent
SevereTransfer: insure it (death, disability, lawsuits, house fire)Avoid it (high-risk activities, ventures you can't afford to lose)
MildRetain: pay yourself (small damage, minor claims)Reduce and retain: prevention, budgeting, maintenance

Where do people usually get it backward?

  • Low deductibles on cars and homes, paying extra premium to avoid small bills, while carrying too little liability coverage.
  • Extended warranties and small-ticket insurance on gadgets.
  • No disability coverage on the paycheck that funds everything else.
  • Life insurance sized by a round number instead of by what the family would actually need.
  • No umbrella policy, even with a teen driver, a pool or a rental property.
  • A business with no plan for losing a key person or partner.

How does wealth change the approach?

As wealth grows, you can retain more: higher deductibles, perhaps self-funding some long-term care. But you need more protection against lawsuits and catastrophic loss. A family with modest savings may need to insure more risks, because they can't absorb many shocks. A wealthy family can drop small coverages and spend the savings on bigger liability limits and better-designed policies. The method is the same either way.

Your one move

List your five biggest "what ifs": death, disability, a lawsuit, a long-term care need, losing a key person in your business. For each, write down whether you're avoiding, reducing, keeping or insuring it today, and how much it would cost your family if it happened tomorrow. Any line that says "keeping it" with a number you couldn't survive is your priority.

Next steps

Sources

  1. Standard risk management framework used in the CFP® curriculum (risk avoidance, reduction, retention and transfer).
  2. National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) consumer guides.