Retirement

Sequence-of-Returns Risk: Why a Bad Market Early in Retirement Hurts Most

The short answer

Sequence-of-returns risk is the danger that markets fall just as you start taking money out. While you're working and adding money, a crash is painful but temporary. Once you're withdrawing, selling investments while they're down locks in losses. Then even a good recovery may not refill the account. The first five to ten years of retirement matter most, and a few simple defenses help a lot.

Two people can earn the same average return over 30 years and end up with very different results, purely because of the order.

Words to know

Sequence of returns
the order in which good and bad years arrive.
Withdrawal rate
the share of your portfolio you take out each year.
Cash reserve (or bucket)
money set aside in cash or short-term bonds to cover spending for a year or two.
Bond ladder
bonds that mature one after another, each covering a future year's spending.

Why does the order matter?

Here's a simple example. Start with $1 million and withdraw $50,000 at the start of the year. If the market then falls 25%, you're left with about $712,500. To get back to $1 million, you'd need a gain of about 40%, and you're still withdrawing every year while you wait.

The same 25% drop at age 50, while you're still adding money, often turns into a buying opportunity. At 66 it can permanently shrink what's left.

Who is most exposed?

  • New retirees, especially in the first five years.
  • People who retire with most of their money in stocks.
  • People with high withdrawal rates or little guaranteed income.
  • People who sell a business and then live off the proceeds right away.

The risk scales with the dollars, but the math is the same for a $500,000 retirement and a $20 million one.

How do people defend against it?

  1. Keep a spending reserve. One to two years of withdrawals in cash or short-term bonds, so you don't have to sell stocks in a downturn.
  2. Be flexible. Agree in advance to trim spending, such as skipping a big trip or holding back an inflation raise, in years after markets fall.
  3. Cover essential spending with guaranteed income. Social Security, a pension or an income annuity can cover the basics. Delaying Social Security raises that floor.
  4. Lower risk around the retirement date. Many people gradually shift some money from stocks to bonds in the years just before and after retiring, then rebuild later.
  5. Watch your withdrawal rate. The higher it is, the less room you have for a bad start.

Your one move

If you're within five years of retiring, or recently retired, work out how many years of spending you could cover without selling a single stock. If the answer is under one year, build that reserve now.

Next steps

In the Guide

Chapter 6: Retirement accounts and the saving sequence

Get the free Guide

Then

Find your blind spots

Take the Wealth Builder Score

Sources

  1. Bengen, W. (1994). Determining withdrawal rates using historical data. Journal of Financial Planning, 7(4).
  2. The example is a hypothetical illustration, not a prediction of market returns.