How does an exchange work?
- Hire a qualified intermediary before you close the sale.
- Sell the property. The QI holds the money.
- Within 45 days, identify replacement properties in writing, usually up to three.
- Within 180 days of the sale, close on one or more of them.
- To defer all the tax, buy at least as much property as you sold and reinvest all the cash. Replacing the old debt with new debt or added cash also counts.
When does it make sense?
- You want to stay invested in real estate, and trade up, consolidate, diversify by location, or move from active rentals to less hands-on property.
- You have a large gain and a lot of past depreciation.
- You'd like to keep deferring until the property passes to heirs.
When might it not?
- You want out of real estate, or need the cash.
- The deadlines force you to overpay for a mediocre property. A bad deal can cost more than the tax you saved.
- The gain is small, or you're in a low bracket this year.
Some investors use passive options to finish an exchange, such as Delaware statutory trusts (DSTs). These can carry high fees and limited liquidity, and they deserve the same scrutiny as any packaged investment.
Is this only for big investors?
No. A teacher selling a single rental condo can use a 1031 exchange as readily as a family with a portfolio of buildings. The same deadlines and the same rules apply. The bigger the gain, the more a misstep costs, so the professional team matters more.
Your one move
If you might sell an investment property in the next year, call a qualified intermediary and your CPA before you sign a sale contract. Ask: "What would I owe without an exchange, what would I defer with one, and could I realistically find and close on a replacement within 180 days?"