How does it work in practice?
Say you sold a fund earlier this year for a $20,000 gain. Another holding is down $15,000. If you sell it and immediately buy a similar but not identical fund, so your money stays invested, the $15,000 loss offsets most of the gain. You owe tax on only $5,000. Your portfolio looks almost the same.
If you had no gains, the loss could reduce ordinary income by $3,000 this year and carry the remaining $12,000 forward.
When is it most useful?
- In years with big gains, from a business sale, a concentrated stock sale, rebalancing or real estate.
- After market drops, when many holdings sit below cost.
- For people in high brackets, where each dollar of offset saves more.
- When you're moving out of a concentrated position over time.
What are the traps?
- Wash sales, including automatic dividend reinvestment and purchases in an IRA.
- Lower basis. The new holding starts with a lower cost basis, so part of the saving is a delay, not a permanent cut. It becomes permanent if you later give the asset to charity, hold it until death, or sell in a lower bracket.
- Letting taxes drive investing. Never trade into something you don't want to own just for a loss.
- Trading costs and fund minimums.
Is this only for big portfolios?
No. Anyone with a taxable brokerage account can use it, and the $3,000-a-year ordinary-income offset matters most to households in moderate brackets. Larger portfolios simply get more chances to do it. Many advisers and automated platforms harvest losses all year, not only in December.
Your one move
Log in to your taxable brokerage account and sort holdings by unrealized gain or loss. Note anything down meaningfully, and check whether you have gains this year. Then, with your adviser or tax preparer, pick a similar replacement and mind the 30-day window.