Getting Good Advice

How to Check an Advisor's Record in 10 Minutes

The short answer

Three free websites show nearly every U.S. financial professional's registration, complaints and disciplinary history: FINRA BrokerCheck (brokercheck.finra.org), the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site (adviserinfo.sec.gov) and CFP Board's verify tool (cfp.net/verify-a-cfp-professional). Checking all three takes about ten minutes. Do it before you hire anyone, and every few years after.

Almost nobody does this, and not because it's hard. Once we like and trust someone, checking up on them feels rude. It isn't rude. It's homework.

Words to know

CRD number
a unique ID assigned to every registered firm and financial professional. It's the easiest way to search.
Disclosure
any reportable event on someone's record: a customer complaint, a regulator's action, a criminal charge, a bankruptcy or a firing.
Form ADV Part 2A
an adviser firm's plain-language brochure covering services, fees, conflicts and discipline.
Form CRS
a short summary every adviser and broker must give you. It's designed so you can compare firms side by side.
U5
the form a firm files when someone leaves. It can show whether they were fired, and why.

Why bother checking?

Because records matter. A major 2019 study in the Journal of Political Economy found that about 7% of U.S. advisers and brokers had a misconduct record. Many who were fired for misconduct were working at another firm within a year. A 2012 study in the Journal of Financial Economics found that past problems disclosed in advisers' public filings helped predict future fraud.

Most advisers have clean records. But you can't tell which ones by how nice the office is or how much you like them.

The 10-minute check

  1. BrokerCheck, minutes 1–3. Search the person's name at brokercheck.finra.org and open the full report. Look at the count of disclosures. If it isn't zero, read each one: what was alleged, how much money was involved, and how it ended.
  2. SEC adviser search, minutes 4–6. Search the person and the firm at adviserinfo.sec.gov. Open the firm's Form ADV Part 2A and read the sections on fees and compensation, other financial industry affiliations and disciplinary information.
  3. CFP Board, minutes 7–8. If they say they're a CFP® professional, confirm it at cfp.net/verify-a-cfp-professional and look for any public discipline.
  4. The firm itself, minutes 9–10. Search the firm's name, not just the person's. A firm with repeated regulatory problems is a warning sign even if your adviser's own record is clean.

What counts as a red flag?

  • Regulatory actions for fraud, taking client money, unauthorized trading or excessive trading. These follow formal investigations.
  • Being fired after a customer complaint or internal review.
  • Several complaints about the same kind of problem, even if each was settled. One dispute can be a misunderstanding. Five about the same thing are a pattern.
  • Criminal records involving money: fraud, theft, forgery.
  • Lots of short stints at different firms, especially firms with their own problems.

A settled complaint doesn't prove wrongdoing, and a single old item isn't necessarily disqualifying. Read the details, then ask the person about it directly. How they answer tells you a lot.

What the records won't show

  • Private warnings from regulators, firms or CFP Board.
  • Some confidential settlements.
  • Problems no one ever reported, such as quiet overcharging, poor tax handling or more risk than you agreed to.

So a clean record is necessary but not enough. Combine it with the questions in the other articles in this section.

Your one move

Pick the person who manages your money now, or the one you're considering, and run the 10-minute check today. It costs nothing, and checking on someone you trust is just responsible.

Next steps

Sources

  1. Egan, M., Matvos, G., & Seru, A. (2019). The market for financial adviser misconduct. Journal of Political Economy, 127(1).
  2. Dimmock, S., & Gerken, W. (2012). Predicting fraud by investment managers. Journal of Financial Economics, 105(1).
  3. Gennaioli, N., Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. (2015). Money doctors. Journal of Finance, 70(1).
  4. FINRA BrokerCheck; SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure; CFP Board verification tool.