What can they offer?
- Access to companies and loans that aren't in public markets.
- Possibly different return patterns from stocks and bonds.
- For some strategies, income or inflation sensitivity.
What do they cost you?
- Fees. A common structure is a yearly management fee plus a share of profits. The traditional "2 and 20" means 2% a year plus 20% of gains. Costs are often several times those of an index fund.
- Lockups. Money can be tied up for years, with limited or no ability to withdraw.
- Smoothed values. Because private holdings are valued by estimate, reported swings can look calmer than the real risk.
- Complexity. Late tax forms (K-1s), capital calls on someone else's schedule, and hard-to-read documents.
- Wide dispersion. The gap between the best and worst private funds is huge, and the best are hardest to get into.
Why are you hearing about them more?
The industry is actively marketing private investments to individuals, including through new "evergreen" and interval funds and, increasingly, retirement plans. Some of these products are useful. Others mainly add fees and illiquidity to people who don't need either.
How should you evaluate one?
- What problem does it solve that your stocks, bonds and cash can't?
- Could you live without this money for the full lockup, plus a few years?
- What are all the fees, in dollars, under a few return scenarios?
- How is it valued, and how and when can you get out?
- Who gets paid if you invest: the manager, the platform, the person recommending it?
Many large endowments and family offices use alternatives. They also have long time horizons, dedicated staff and access to top managers. Most individuals, at any wealth level, are better served with a small, deliberate allocation or none at all.
Your one move
If you own alternatives now, make a one-page list: what you own, what you committed and how much is still uncalled, the fees, the lockup end date, and the latest valuation date. If you're being pitched one, ask the five questions above in writing before you sign.